Missouri Governor Resumes Death Penalty Case Despite New DNA Evidence in Convict’s Favor

Missouri Governor Mike Parson has announced the continuation of a death penalty case against Marcellus Williams, who claims innocence in the stabbing death of former newspaper reporter Lisha Gayle. The governor disbanded a panel of former judges responsible for reviewing Williams’ case and lifted the stay on his execution, without setting a specific date. Williams was convicted of killing Gayle during a burglary at her University City home in 1998. However, new DNA evidence found on the murder weapon, which did not match Williams, has cast doubt on his guilt.

Former Governor Eric Greitens intervened just hours before Williams was scheduled to be executed five years ago, ordering an investigation based on the newly discovered DNA testing. The results indicated that the DNA found on the murder weapon did not belong to Williams but to an unknown person. Despite the evidence, Parson’s decision to resume the death penalty case has been met with criticism. The Innocence Project’s co-founder, Barry Scheck, argued that the doubt surrounding the case should lead to Williams’ sentence being commuted, as the DNA on the murder weapon does not match him.

Prosecutors presented other evidence to secure Williams’ conviction, including a stolen jacket used to conceal bloodstains, witness testimonies, and alleged confessions. However, Williams’ defense team has pointed out that the girlfriend and a fellow inmate who provided testimony were both convicted felons with a financial incentive. The case has also raised concerns about racial disparities within the criminal justice system. Gayle’s family expressed their understanding of the need for careful scrutiny but emphasized the pain they endure throughout the ongoing legal process.

Pic Courtesy: google/ images are subject to copyright